For 27 years, Sweetness Marabulela has opened the doors of Entokozweni Day Care Centre in Orange Farm, south of Johannesburg, to the community's youngest children. Today 32 children are enrolled. Parents pay R350 a month, and she also takes in children whose families cannot pay.
On 19 November 2026, the 63-year-old was convicted in the Vereeniging Magistrates' Court for running the centre without a health permit required by the City of Johannesburg's public health bylaws.
What the court decided
Marabulela was first fined R5,000 on 26 August for operating without the permit. The court has now sentenced her to a R1,000 fine or 30 days in prison, suspended for five years on condition that she does not operate without a permit.
She has been granted leave to appeal, and the appeal is set for 2 December 2026. Cases against two other early childhood development (ECD) owners have been postponed to January and February 2027 while the appeal goes ahead.
Lawyers for Human Rights, which represents her, said: "The charge against Mam Sweetness concerned a missing permit. It did not allege any risk to children's health or safety."
Why so many crèches cannot get a permit
To get the permit, applicants must provide a title deed or lease, zoning consent if they care for more than six children, approved building plans and a fire safety inspection. Marabulela's centre is on municipal land, but she has never been given a lease or contract by the municipality, so she cannot meet the first requirement.
She is not alone. The advocacy group Real Reform for ECD estimates that about 200 centres in the City's Region G struggle to get health permits.
"Despite being called a health permit, it has little to do with actual health," said Nobukhosi Zulu of Real Reform for ECD.
LHR attorney David Dickinson said: "Hundreds of ECD centres are unable to comply with the law and are being dragged into court and criminalised."
What happens next
Lawyers for Human Rights has asked the court to drop the fines and charges and has urged the City to negotiate before more ECD operators are prosecuted. Real Reform for ECD is collecting signatures for a petition to end the criminalisation of crèche owners, which it plans to hand to City officials.
For working parents in townships, a neighbourhood crèche is often the only affordable childcare there is. If centres like Entokozweni close, the impact is felt far beyond one owner.



