Minister in the Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities Sindisiwe Chikunga wants municipalities to stop outsourcing basic services through tenders and to employ young people directly instead.
She made the proposal in a keynote address at a Youth Employment Roundtable at the CSA International Convention Centre in Kempton Park on Thursday 19 November.
What she proposed
"The tender system for basic municipal services must be scrapped and replaced with sustainable public employment," Chikunga said. She proposed that municipalities hire unemployed youth according to their qualifications:
- Matric holders: reading meters, collecting refuse, maintaining roads and parks, and staffing call centres.
- TVET graduates: working as plumbers, electricians, mechanics, and water and wastewater plant operators.
- University graduates: filling roles such as civil engineers, town planners and ICT specialists.
Direct employment would also let young people work near home instead of moving to the big cities, she said.
Her criticism of outsourcing
Chikunga said outsourcing creates only temporary jobs. "The young person hired for six months goes home when the contract closes," she said.
She said municipalities pay contractors for work their own staff could do and rely on consultants for tasks that qualified staff could handle. "We have municipalities without a single qualified engineer, in a country with unemployed engineering graduates," she said.
The services she cited include water supply, sanitation, electricity distribution, refuse removal, road maintenance and the upkeep of public facilities.
What we do not yet know
- The cost of the proposal, and who would pay for it.
- Whether it would need changes to municipal procurement or finance legislation.
- Whether Cabinet or National Treasury has endorsed it. The statement we reviewed presents it as a proposal, and it gives no figures on youth unemployment, municipal staffing or contract costs.



