Only 8.6% of reported rape cases in South Africa end in a conviction, according to Amnesty International South Africa, which launched new research this week at Constitution Hill in Johannesburg. The organisation says the figure is far lower than the 74.8% conviction rate cited by the Department of Justice.

Amnesty director Shenilla Mohamed attributed the 8.6% figure to the Medical Research Council, which she said offers the more realistic picture. "Our government, our department of justice, is telling us that they have a conviction rate of 74.8%," she said.

What the study found

The research draws on a national study of 3,952 reported rape cases. As presented by Amnesty, the cases fell away at these stages:

  • 35% were closed by police.
  • 31% were declined by prosecutors.
  • 16% were struck from the court roll.
  • 19% proceeded to trial.

Why cases fall away

Amnesty says survivors may withdraw because of trauma, safety concerns, financial and practical barriers, pressure from family or community, or low trust in the system. It also points to failures inside the system: poor treatment when reporting, weak statements and investigations, mishandled or missing dockets, forensic delays, poor communication, and cases closed without explanation.

It identified six problem areas in police engagement: reporting, statement-taking, a lack of victim-friendly rooms, investigations, communication and forensic capacity. Mohamed also pointed to the DNA backlog.

What Amnesty wants

Amnesty made recommendations to the South African Police Service, the National Prosecuting Authority and the National Council on Gender-Based Violence and Femicide:

  • Strengthen specialised sexual offences investigation capacity.
  • Improve statement-taking practices.
  • Ensure early consultation between prosecutors and investigators.
  • Publish quarterly rape case attrition reports, covering investigation rates, prosecution rates, cases declined by prosecutors, cases discontinued after survivors disengage, and trial outcomes.

Amnesty campaigner Cassandra Dorasamy said recognising rape case attrition as a national accountability indicator is key. "Closing that gap is essential if the criminal justice system is to fulfil its constitutional obligations," she said.

The research comes days before the annual 16 Days of Activism for No Violence Against Women and Children, which runs from 25 November to 10 December.

What we do not yet know

  • What the 8.6% measures. Reports of the launch describe it both as the share of all reported cases that end in conviction and as the share of cases that went to trial, and the two are very different.
  • The period the study covers and how it was conducted; neither was stated in the reporting we reviewed.
  • How the Department of Justice calculates its 74.8% figure, and whether the department has responded to Amnesty's findings.