Opinion

A parliamentary reply this week gave South Africans a number they can hold on to: 936 women reported missing since April 2025 are still unresolved. What it did not give them is the one thing needed to judge the other number, the 1,048 cases police call resolved.

The number that is missing

According to Acting Police Minister Firoz Cachalia's written reply, 1,984 missing women cases were registered between 1 April 2025 and 30 September 2026. The reply says 1,048 are resolved and 936 are pending. It does not say what resolved means, and it says that finding out would need a manual validation that would divert officers from operational duties.

That answer is understandable as a matter of workload. It is not acceptable as a matter of public trust. A case closed because a woman was found safe is a success. A case closed because a body was found is a murder docket. A case closed because the report was withdrawn is something else again. The same word cannot cover all three.

A week of hard facts

The reply arrived in the same week as the release of the July to September crime statistics, which police said showed 5,590 murders in three months. Reports on those statistics said 581 women were killed in the quarter, while also noting that police have stopped publishing women's murder figures, citing "significant anomalies".

On Wednesday night five women and a two-year-old boy were shot dead at a home in Botshabelo, in the Free State. Gauteng's police commissioner, General Tommy Mthombeni, said on Thursday that eight people had been arrested in connection with 13 women's murders in and around Johannesburg.

What should happen next

Three modest changes would make the figures worth something. Police should define "resolved" in public and report the outcome of every closed case in broad categories. They should restore the publication of women's murder figures, with an explanation of the anomalies they found. And they should give Parliament and families a timeline for how quickly a missing woman's case is expected to move.

None of this requires new money or new legislation. It requires a decision that the numbers belong to the public they describe.

The police say these cases are a priority. A priority can be measured. Until it is, families of the missing are left with the one word nobody has explained.