Developing story: coalition talks are under way and positions may change. This article will be updated.
Democratic Alliance (DA) leader Geordin Hill-Lewis says his party is discussing ActionSA's demand that it drop Helen Zille as its Johannesburg mayoral candidate and Cilliers Brink in Tshwane. He called the request "extraordinarily difficult for us to swallow".
Hill-Lewis spoke in a radio interview on Monday 16 November, as parties entered a crunch week for forming councils after the 4 November local elections.
What ActionSA is asking for
ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba has said he will not work with the DA in other municipalities while Zille and Brink remain its candidates. He made the point after meeting Hill-Lewis about coalition arrangements in several parts of the country.
ActionSA national chairperson Michael Beaumont avoided the phrase "red line". He described the demand as a "very strong request" that the party would find hard to move off, and said the issue was management track record rather than personalities. He described Brink as a failed mayor and said: "We do not put in failed mayors to lead municipalities." He also accused Zille of being central to the collapse of stable coalitions in Johannesburg.
Beaumont said ActionSA is also talking to the African National Congress (ANC) and is open to coalitions on either side of the political divide. He said the DA could propose its own solution to the impasse.
How the DA responded
Hill-Lewis said the DA is considering all prospective partners' requests, including ActionSA's, without ruling anything out. He said dropping Zille may not be fair to Johannesburg voters, because the DA won the largest share of the vote in the city.
He rejected the language of "red lines" and "no deal", saying it was a poor basis for negotiation and that the DA had sent the wrong signal by refusing to talk to some parties. "Our prospective partners must know that we do have other options," he said. He said the parties were "very far apart" on several issues, but that the relationship was not broken and the DA would keep talking to ActionSA.
Political analyst Theo Neethling said removing Zille would be problematic and that Mashaba risked overplaying his hand by making a personal objection a condition for cooperation. He also warned that parties may put their own power interests ahead of stable municipal governance, and that hasty deals built around dividing posts could cause further instability.
The ANC and the national government
Hill-Lewis said he had noted reports that the ANC's National Executive Committee prefers coalition arrangements that exclude the DA, but declined to discuss the details of those talks. The ANC and the DA met for about three hours on Sunday. The DA has released a set of coalition principles that includes zero tolerance for corruption, merit-based appointments and accountability.
Asked about the DA's place in the government of national unity (GNU), Hill-Lewis did not rule out a review. He said the question would be raised in the coming months and that he expects a tense period.
What we do not yet know
- Whether the DA will change either candidate. No decision has been announced and no date has been given.
- Whether ActionSA will reach a deal with the ANC instead. Both parties say talks are continuing.
- How the parties will meet the deadline. Councils must hold their first meetings within 14 days of councillors being gazetted last week, and reports put the deadline at 27 November.
The parties have agreed not to negotiate through the media until they publish their coalition agreements, according to reports. No publication date has been given.



